Skip Navigation

Cleansing Oil Vs Cleansing Balm: Unveiling the 5 Best-Kept Secrets for Your Skin!

In the world of skincare, where every product promises radiant and brighter skin, two competitors stand out as heroes of the cleansing game : cleansing oil Vs cleansing balms. Both of these layout foundation of your skincare routine and make your skin a clean canvas to absorb and enhance the effect of coming products.

Cleansing Oil Vs Cleansing Balm
Cleansing Oil Vs Cleansing Balm

Imagine this, after a long tiring day at work where continuous choices had to be made between different options, you finally come back to home to rest and do some self-love practice – skincare! And there it is ,you again have a choice to make : cleansing balm or cleansing oil ? Which one will remove your makeup ? which one will suit your skin type?  Which one’s better? Cleansing Oil Vs Cleansing Balm?

This article will help you to explore in depth what these two heroes Cleansing Oil Vs Cleansing Balm have to offer. By the end of this, you will not only know the difference between the two but will also be able to choose which one suits you Cleansing Oil Vs Cleansing Balm the best and give you optimum results.

Let’s uncover the secret which one to prefer : Cleansing Oil Vs Cleansing Balm.

Cleansing oil

cleansing oil 1

 Cleansing oil is a skincare product having oil like consistency. It is a blend of different oils including mineral oil, botanical oil and synthetic oil.

The hype around cleansing oils is grounded in their effectiveness and versatility. They’ve garnered attention for their ability to dissolve makeup, even stubborn waterproof products, while maintaining the skin’s natural moisture barrier. This multi-functional nature, capable of both cleansing and nourishing the skin, has propelled their popularity. Additionally, the censorial experience—massaging an oil into the skin and then emulsifying it for easy removal—has added to their allure.

With various oil types catering to different skin needs, the hype around cleansing oils also lies in their adaptability for various skin types, from dry to sensitive skin. The notion that an oil-based product can effectively cleanse without stripping the skin of its natural oils has further fuelled the hype, making them a sought-after choice in skincare routines.

It is used to remove makeup , dirt and other impurities from skin. When applied, cleansing oil breaks and dissolve these substances ,allowing them to be easily wiped or rinsed off. They are used in double cleansing method. Where you first use an oil based cleanser followed by a gel based cleanser. It ensures that the skin is clean and hydrated.

Cleansing balm

cleansing balm

Cleansing balm, on the other hand, is a skincare product that has solid or semi-solid consistency that transforms into oil like consistency when it comes in contact with warmth of your skin. It is designed to e used for initial step of double cleansing process where it removes makeup, dirt and impurities from skin. They are gentle in nature,  have nourishing properties which make them suitable for various skin types including sensitive skin. They leave the skin feeling clean and hydrated after use.

Why proper cleansing is important ?

Cleansing in the first and foremost important step in skincare routine. When comparing cleansing oil vs. cleansing balm, it’s vital to understand their unique cleansing properties. Any other product will not be effective unless you have cleansed your skin properly. Proper cleansing ensures that all the dirt, oil, impurities, dust and makeup is removed from your skin and your skin is ready to absorb other products.

 Proper cleansing is foundation of healthy skincare routine. It helps maintain your skin to be clear, youthful and radiant while improving the effectiveness of other skincare products. Skipping cleansing can give rise to a lot of problems including breakouts, acne and uneven skin tone.

Now that we know importance of cleansing , lets talk about which is better for cleansing : Cleansing balm Vs Cleansing oil ?

Ingredient List of Cleansing Oil Vs Cleansing Balm

To effectively understand the effects of cleansing oil vs. balm, knowing the ingredients used in both aids in choosing the ideal skincare solution.

Cleansing oil

  • Botanical Extracts: Plant-based extracts such as chamomile, lavender, or rose hip offer soothing and nourishing effects.
  • Antioxidants: Components like vitamin E or green tea extract provide skin-soothing and protective properties in cleansing oils.
  • Fragrance or Essential Oils: These are sometimes added for aroma or supplementary skincare benefits, but they might cause skin irritation in some individuals.

Cleansing balm

  • Emollients: Natural oils like olive, coconut, or sunflower seed oils for breaking down makeup and providing hydration.
  • Antioxidants: Elements like vitamin E, green tea, or grape seed extract for skin-soothing and protection.
  • Fragrance or Essential Oils: Often included for fragrance or additional skincare benefits, but potential sources of skin irritation.
  • Natural Extracts: Botanical extracts like chamomile, lavender for calming and soothing properties in some balms.

Application : how to apply Cleansing Oil Vs Cleansing Balm?

Whether it’s gently massaging a nourishing cleansing balm or applying a light, hydrating cleansing oil, the key lies in a soothing, circular motion for a thorough cleanse.

Cleansing oil : how to use?

  • Start with dry hands and apply a coin-sized amount of oil to your face.
  • Massage in upward circular motions, avoiding the eye area initially.
  • Use a small amount on a cotton pad to remove eye makeup gently.
  • Wet hands and continue massaging to emulsify the oil.
  • Rinse with lukewarm water, ensuring complete removal of oil and makeup.
  • Gently pat dry with a towel.

Cleansing balm : how to use?

  • Start with dry hands and apply a coin-sized amount of oil to your face.
  • Massage in upward circular motions, avoiding the eye area initially.
  • Use a small amount on a cotton pad to remove eye makeup gently.
  • Wet hands and continue massaging to emulsify the oil.
  • Rinse with lukewarm water, ensuring complete removal of oil and makeup.
  • Gently pat dry with a towel.

Cleansing oil – Pros and Cons

Here is a list of advantages and drawbacks of cleansing oil Vs cleansing balm to choose the one best suited for you.


  • Anti-aging benefits :  Many cleansing oil has antioxidant properties like Vitamin E and botanical extracts which contributes to the youthfulness of skin. They prevent pre-mature aging along with effective cleansing.
  • Lightweight texture :  The lightweight texture of cleansing oil makes it very likeable. They have thinner texture the cleansing balms which makes them quickly absorbs in skin.
  • Easy usage : Cleansing oils come in pump bottles that are very easy to use . they ensure minimal waste and gets you just the right amount of product.
  • Effective makeup removal : One of the most important benefit of cleansing oil is its ability to remove makeup. It can remove waterproof makeup and long lasting products. The reason behind this is simple : “like dissolves like”. They are very gently around eye area and easily removes eye makeup including mascara and eyeliner.
  • Quick emulsification : Cleansing oils tends to emulsify quickly then cleansing balms when mixed with water. This is effective if you prefer quicker rinsing off process.
  • Suitable for acne prone skin : Cleansing oils can be suitable for acne prone skin, if the product is chosen carefully .


  • Residue : One main issue many can face while using cleansing oil is leftover residue. While it may not be a problem for everyone , but for those who prefer a complete clean and matte feel on their skin.
  • Not ideal for oily skin : Since main ingredients in cleansing oils are oils. They are not suitable for oily skin as it may make the skin oily. This can cause several problems for oily skin individuals.
  • Costly : Really good and effective oil cleansers are very costly in market. This can be a drawback for those who wants to practice skincare within a small budget.
  • Sensitivity to ingredients : Some ingredients in cleansing oil may cause some reaction , especially for people who have sensitive skin types.  Fragrances or some other commonly used ingredients can cause itching or irritation.
  • Potential breakouts : Inadequate rinsing and product residue may cause clogged pores, eventually leading to breakouts. Make sure you rinse the product off thoroughly to avoid this.

Cleansing balm – Pros and Cons


  • Deep cleansing : Cleansing balms are famous for their ability to deeply and thoroughly cleanse. They are very effective at removing makeup, sunscreen , dust and other impurities from skin. Their transformation from solid texture to oil like consistency make them able to penetrate deep into your pores , dissolving even the most stubborn makeup and impurities.
  • Ideal for dry skin : Another benefit of cleansing balm is its effectiveness for dry skin. These balms have very hydrating ingredients like shea butter, cocoa butter and other that aids in providing moisture and hydration to dry skin along with cleansing.
  • Gentle on skin : Cleansing balms are very gentle on skin making it suitable for various skin types including sensitive skin. Unlike other cleansing products, cleansing balms do not leave your skin dry or rough after use. They gently and effectively cleanse your skin.
  • Makeup removal : Cleansing balms cleanses off makeup effectively. If used properly, it can be proven effective to remove heavy makeup and eye makeup such as mascara and eyeliner.
  • Spa-like experience :  The act of massaging these balms onto your skin feels like a mini spa experience . Moreover , the beautiful scent and texture of these balms makes the easy to use making you feel pampered . This aspect of cleansing balms makes it favorite of those who cherish the pampering aspect of skincare.
  • Acne-prone skin : Cleansing balms can be effective for active prone skin when chosen carefully, considering the formulation and individual’s skin sensitivities.


  • Residue: Some cleansing balms might leave a residue on the skin if not rinsed off thoroughly, which can feel heavy or greasy.
  • Ingredients Sensitivity: Fragrances or certain ingredients in cleansing balms could potentially cause skin irritation or breakouts for some individuals with sensitive skin.
  • Potential Clogged Pores: While effective at removing makeup, if not completely removed, the residue could potentially clog pores, leading to breakouts.
  • Thicker Texture: The thicker texture of some balms might be less preferred by those who prefer lighter or more easily spreadable cleansers.
  • Not Suitable for All Skin Types: Some balms might not be ideal for oily or acne-prone skin due to their heavier consistency.
  • Require More Effort to Rinse: Some cleansing balms might require more effort and time to thoroughly rinse off, especially compared to lighter cleansing options.
  • Packaging Concerns: Certain balm packaging, especially in jars, might be less hygienic over time as you repeatedly dip fingers in or might be less travel-friendly compared to pump or tube packaging.
  • Price Point: High-quality cleansing balms with specific ingredients can be more expensive compared to other cleansing options, potentially affecting their affordability for some users.


Cleansing balm and cleansing oil each have their unique strengths and weaknesses. The choice between Cleansing oil Vs Cleansing balm the two ultimately comes down to your lifestyle, skin type , skin concerns  and personal preference. Whether you opt for lightweight texture of cleansing oil or soothing luxury of cleansing balm, both can be valuable addition to your skincare regime. Remember to prioritise products that do not clog pores and are suitable for your skin type. With the right choice, you can enjoy effective makeup removal and a freshly cleaned canvas for your skincare journey.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better cleansing balm or oil?

Both cleansing balms and oils are excellent at removing makeup and dirt. The best one for you depends on what you like. Balms have a thicker texture and can feel more nourishing, while oils are lighter. If you have oily skin, you might prefer a lighter oil. If your skin is dry, you might like the extra moisture from a balm. Try both and see which one feels better for your skin!

Can I use oil instead of cleansing balm?

Yes, you can use cleansing oil instead of a balm. Both work to clean your skin by removing makeup and dirt. Oils are lighter in texture compared to balms. So, if you prefer something lighter, the oil could be a good alternative. Just make sure it suits your skin type and feels comfortable for you.

Which one to use for acne cleansing oil or cleansing balm?

Both cleansing balms and oils can work well for acne. However, it depends on your skin. Some people find that lighter oils suit their acne-prone skin better as they’re less likely to clog pores. Others prefer balms for their nourishing feel. It’s essential to choose products labelled noncomedogenic (won’t clog pores) and consider consulting a dermatologist to find the best option for your specific skin concerns.